(Image: Header Graphic)

Monday, July 13, 2020

Doug's Domain

Doug Vetter, ATP/CFI

Like what you see?

Donations to dvatp.com are now processed via Stripe. Like this site? It's easier than ever to show your appreciation.

Saturday, March 12, 2011

Purchase of Summer Wheels and Tires

Ever since I saw the benefit of moving to dedicated performance winter tires I've thought about going back to dedicated high performance summer-only rubber. I could never justify the cost of a set of Pilot Sport PS2 in 18" fitment, however, so I just stuck with the Pilot Sport A/S Plus. That got me to thinking (always a dangerous thing, I know). What if I downsized to a set of 17 inch wheels? That would have several benefits including lower weight, improved braking and acceleration performance (due to more of the wheel's mass being closer to the center of rotation), AND lower tire cost.

(Image: Set of M Contour wheels with PS2 installed) But the question remained. How much could I really expect to save by buying 17 vs 18 inch tires? Does $300 for a set of four PS2's sound like a lot of money? It certainly does to me. In fact, that was the catalyst for finding a new set of 17 inch wheels. I looked in the aftermarket and found it had largely abandoned the 17 inch wheel market with the exception of expensive lightweight wheels designed more for track duty than encounters with potholes on public roads. I also looked at BMW-centric aftermarket manufacturers including recognized BMW wheel designer BBS, but with their prices exceeding those of BMW's own offerings I quickly abandoned that pursuit.

Given my recent experience with the refinished Style 30 wheel I began to entertain the idea of just buying a set of refinished OE wheels native to either the E36 or E46. I had always admired the stock 17" Style 68 wheels on the E46 and I had found enough pictures to confirm they would not clash with the lines of the E36. The problem? Evidently the people at Wheel Collision took a close look at the BMW price book, because they seemed to consistently charge 90+% of retail for their offerings. For used wheels with a finish that does not, unfortunately, match the consistency and quality of the OE wheels? If that's my choice, the decision is a no-brainer -- I'll buy new.

So that brought me full circle -- right back to realoem.com and the list of wheels that were originally offered on the E36. I'd always been partial to the Style 23 wheel, otherwise known as the M Contour II, which was fit to M3's equipped with the premium package from 1996-1999. I checked the price at Tischer and was shocked to discover these wheels were literally half the cost of other M-branded wheels such as the Style 68's. With the 2010 financials still fresh in my mind I must confess I wasn't exactly eager to drop another $1300 on a set of wheels, no matter the perceived "savings". But with warmer weather fast approaching I decided to leverage a tax refund, some petty cash, and funds freed by my friend's recent decision to sell the Skyhawk, and throw down an order for a set of Style 23's.

With the purchase decision out of the way, the only question that remained was: staggered or non-staggered? Staggered wheels get a bum rap from people who say they "increase understeer". As I've argued before, that's not entirely true. What they do is reduce oversteer, which is not the same thing. And while decreasing the width of the tire in the front by 10mm is bound to have a negative effect on grip, I believe this will be easily offset relative to the A/S by the increased performance of the no-compromise PS2 tread compound and configuration. So I decided to order three 17x7.5" (yes, I believe in full-size spares...take that E90 owners!) and two 17x8.5" for the rear and wrap them all with PS2 rubber.

And speaking of rubber, when I called Tire Rack to place the order I realized once again why I deal with them. All I had to do was give them my name, the order specifics, and a credit card. They already had my billing and shipping information and offered to ship the tires to my dealer again. The entire process took less than two minutes. Before giving me the total price, the rep advised me that Michelin was starting a spring promotion the following day involving a $70 mail-in rebate and offered to delay posting the order until the next day so I could take advantage of the rebate. I was in no rush so I agreed, and in doing so reduced the tire cost from $850 to $780.

If you're wondering what will happen to the CSLs, the current plan is to send them to Wheel Collision later this year for refinishing, equip them with another set of Pilot Sport A/S, and mount them on the E46 in November so it may serve its role as a backup vehicle should the E36 decide to give up the ghost in the dead of winter. For accounting purposes, anything I do to those wheels at this point will be considered an E46 expense, and in that context the $825 Wheel Collision quoted me for refinishing really isn't a bad deal for a set of attractive wheels that will look more at home on the E46 by virtue of the fact that they were originally designed for it.

Lift Shopping

While slightly off the central topic of BMW maintenance, I figured I'd report my findings in my recent search for an automotive service lift for my brother's new garage. The goal was simply to understand the market, select a unit, and get a quote for both the lift and installation. My brother had only two requirements: the ability to lift all the vehicles in his fleet, ranging from an early 80's Chevette nostalgia car to his BMW, all the way up to the small box trucks used in his business, and a maximum ceiling height of 14 feet. So here's what I learned.

At this point I had narrowed the selection of lifts down to the specific type and capacity. The next order of business was to select a vendor and compare prices. To keep the work to a minimum, I focused on the following three vendors, all of whom are well known in the industry and favored on the various forums I read:

So at the end of the day I submitted my recommendation for a Rotary 12K two post lift to my brother. Now it's in his hands to pull the trigger or look for alternatives. Groundbreaking is scheduled for sometime this week but it's been delayed for a number of reasons already so anything is possible. Hopefully a lift will be among the first things installed in the completed building sometime this summer. I'm still hoping that I can do my front suspension overhaul on the lift, but logistics (as well as the mess of fluids I'm sure it will generate) may actually favor the old garage, its "well used" floor, and a set of jackstands.

Mileage: 205000, Parts $2130